Best foreclosure attorneys in Orange Park
This ranks the top 15 Orange Park attorneys who list foreclosure-related work by earned composite score, built from real client feedback rather than paid placement (see our methodology). Most of these are general practice offices where foreclosure defense sits alongside estate, bankruptcy, family, and real estate law, so the reviews behind each score often reflect that broader mix of work.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sermons Law, PLLC | 87 | 4.9 (187) | — | Full-service firm, start-to-finish attorney |
| 2 | Donley Law Firm, PLLC | 87 | 4.8 (96) | — | Accessible, straight-talking counsel |
| 3 | The Law Offices Of Ron Sholes, P.A. | 87 | 4.7 (122) | — | Fast-moving, personal case handling |
| 4 | Morgan & Morgan | 82 | 4.8 (1708) | — | High-volume firm, simple intake |
| 5 | Law Office of Tony Turner Orange Park Bankruptcy Lawyer | 81 | 4.6 (78) | — | Bankruptcy filings tied to foreclosure |
| 6 | Empowerment Legal, PLLC | 81 | 4.9 (17) | — | Veterans' claims and immigration |
| 7 | Berg Bryant Elder Law Group, PLLC | 78 | 4.7 (15) | — | Elder law and Medicaid planning |
| 8 | Owenby Law, P.A. | 76 | 4.5 (279) | — | Family law with standout individual attorneys |
| 9 | David A. King | 75 | 4.9 (16) | — | Estate planning and real estate matters |
| 10 | Henry & Henry Law Firm | 73 | 4.9 (27) | — | Bankruptcy filings, direct attorney access |
| 11 | Taylor, Glenn A PA | 72 | 4.6 (25) | — | Real estate closings and title work |
| 12 | Hamilton&Hartin | 71 | 4.7 (15) | — | Real estate and family law, small firm |
| 13 | Tolson & Associates, PA | 68 | 4.5 (15) | — | Estate planning and elder law |
| 14 | Law Office of Summer R. Nichols | 64 | 3.9 (34) | — | Divorce cases, when the firm accepts you |
| 15 | Luke Law LLC | 63 | 4.6 (33) | — | Adoption, criminal defense, title disputes |
Ranked picks
Sermons Law, PLLC
Why it ranks first
Sermons Law posts the top composite score here on the strength of nearly 190 reviews and a 4.9 average, with clients repeatedly praising fast callbacks and clear explanations during stressful cases. The firm's site lists foreclosure and loan modification among its services, though most of the review detail here centers on wills, probate, and custody work handled by Markus Sermons, Kyle Marcil, and Jahlysa Jenkins.
Pros
- Same attorney stays on the case from start to finish
- Staff and attorneys pick up the phone directly
- Fees stated upfront according to reviewers
- Offices in both Orange Park and Jacksonville
Watch out: A couple of reviewers flagged surprise consultation charges and a billing dispute after a five-month guardianship case.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Donley Law Firm, PLLC
Why it ranks second
Donley Law Firm scores just behind the top spot, built on a 4.8 average across 96 reviews and strong sentiment. Clients describe Mr. Donley and his team, including Amber Donley and the paralegal staff, as honest and easy to reach, though the review detail here leans toward criminal, juvenile, and traffic matters more than foreclosure specifically.
Pros
- Attorney is responsive and answers questions directly
- Explains legal terms and next steps in plain language
- Reviewers note strong case outcomes
- Fees described as reasonable and affordable
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
The Law Offices Of Ron Sholes, P.A.
Why it ranks third
Ron Sholes' office earns a high composite score on a 4.7 average from 122 reviews, with clients describing quick settlements and staff who keep them informed at every step. The reviews here focus heavily on auto accident cases rather than foreclosure, with named team members Blair Butler, Robyn, and Mia called out repeatedly for personal attention.
Pros
- Reviewers report fast settlement timelines
- Named staff get credited by name for follow-through
- Clients say they felt treated like family, not a file number
- Consistent praise across a large review base
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Morgan & Morgan
Why it ranks fourth
Morgan & Morgan has by far the largest review base on this list at 1,708 reviews and a 4.8 average, which lifts its volume score, but sentiment analysis of the reviews themselves comes in noticeably softer than the smaller local firms above it. New clients often describe a smooth first contact, while several existing clients report weeks-long silences and friction once a case is already underway.
Pros
- 35-year track record and name recognition
- Large volume of positive initial reviews
- Friendly, efficient intake process
- Straightforward first consultations
Watch out: Several reviewers describe slow responses once a case is active, along with disputes over settlement information and file transfers.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Law Office of Tony Turner Orange Park Bankruptcy Lawyer
Why it ranks fifth
Tony Turner's office is one of the closer matches on this list to foreclosure-adjacent work, since much of the caseload described in reviews is Chapter 7 bankruptcy and stopping wage garnishment. With a 4.6 average across 78 reviews and about 88% five-star feedback, clients consistently credit Tony and staff member Nancy for patience and clear step-by-step guidance.
Pros
- 30-plus years of local practice
- Staff stays involved from filing through discharge
- Reviewers describe efficient, responsive handling
- Clients note genuine concern for their financial recovery
Watch out: A handful of reviews mention a disorganized intake process and one report of an abrupt phone manner.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Empowerment Legal, PLLC
Why it ranks sixth
Empowerment Legal earns a strong composite score built on a smaller but very positive review base of 17, with Ms. Parr drawing praise from veterans, immigrants, and even opposing counsel. Reviewers describe her taking on VA disability claims often without upfront fees and immigration cases through detention and deportation proceedings, though this is not primarily a foreclosure practice.
Pros
- Free initial VA claims and consultations
- Prior military background builds trust with veteran clients
- Refers clients elsewhere honestly when she can't help
- Small team stays with cases through resolution
Watch out: The strong rating rests on a relatively small number of reviews.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Berg Bryant Elder Law Group, PLLC
Why it ranks seventh
Berg Bryant Elder Law Group scores well on a smaller sample of 15 reviews at a 4.7 average, with clients specifically naming Carla, Shelby, Cristian, Jenn, and Kellen for walking families through Medicaid qualification and power of attorney paperwork in plain language. This is elder law and estate work rather than foreclosure defense.
Pros
- Staff named repeatedly for patience and responsiveness
- Medicaid qualification process explained clearly
- Accessible scheduling
- Consistent praise across the reviews on file
Watch out: The review count here is modest, so the picture is based on a smaller sample than some competitors.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Owenby Law, P.A.
Why it ranks eighth
Owenby Law carries the second-largest review base on this list at 279 reviews and a 4.5 average, with named attorneys Kyra Lucas-Millbrook, Briana Leshinsky, Renae Kenny, Dustin Nemati, and Sharnice Perry drawing strong individual praise, mostly in family law matters. The sentiment score is pulled down by a recurring pattern of firm-level communication and billing issues that several reviewers describe as separate from the quality of their assigned attorney.
Pros
- Multiple named attorneys with strong individual track records
- Female-forward leadership
- Over 20 years in operation
- Clients report feeling genuinely supported when paired with the right attorney
Watch out: Reviewers describe missed case updates, slow responses, retainer refund delays, and reception staff rudeness.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
David A. King
Why it ranks ninth
David A. King draws a strong 4.9 average, though from a small base of 16 reviews, which is reflected in the lower confidence on this score. Clients describe him as deeply knowledgeable and responsive, with long-standing relationships built over years, but the review detail centers on estate planning and real estate rather than foreclosure or loan modification.
Pros
- Practicing since 2011 with long client relationships
- Highly responsive to client calls
- Strong reputation for estate and real estate work
- Clients describe him as organized and thorough
Watch out: Based on a small number of reviews, so treat the rating as directional rather than exhaustive.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Henry & Henry Law Firm
Why it ranks tenth
Henry & Henry earns a 4.9 average across 27 reviews, with 26 of them describing Todd Henry as present and responsive throughout the case, explaining each step clearly during what are often difficult bankruptcy filings. The lower confidence score here reflects the smaller review count and a somewhat lower recency score than firms higher on this list.
Pros
- Todd Henry personally answers client calls
- Detailed communication by phone and email
- Fees described as affordable for the service level
- Reviewers cite a strong reputation with local judges and trustees
Watch out: One reviewer reported being overcharged on a bankruptcy filing that didn't proceed to completion, with an unfulfilled refund promise.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Taylor, Glenn A PA
Why it ranks #11
Glenn Taylor's office scores well for swift, professional closings, with a 4.6 average across 25 reviews. Most feedback centers on real estate title work across the Jacksonville metro rather than foreclosure defense specifically, and the score carries lower confidence given the smaller review base.
Pros
- Reviewers describe fast, efficient closings
- Staff and attorney described as accessible
- Attorney willing to walk through complex transactions in detail
- Reliable handling of standard transactions
Watch out: A single Orange Park location was noted as a limitation by some reviewers, along with vague cost complaints.
Services: loan modification, short sale deed in lieu, foreclosure defense litigation
Hamilton&Hartin
Why it ranks #12
Hamilton&Hartin earns solid marks on a smaller base of 15 reviews, with Attorney Geraldine Hartin's real estate law background drawing consistent praise alongside staff members Christine, Sandy, and Amy. The lower confidence reflects the limited review volume rather than any negative signal.
Pros
- Attorney Hartin has a strong real estate law reputation
- Named staff praised for patience and accessibility
- Clear communication throughout the process
- Covers multiple practice areas including probate
Watch out: One older review cited a six-month delay in filing paperwork after a deposit was made.
Services: loan modification
Tolson & Associates, PA
Why it ranks #13
Tolson & Associates draws praise for estate planning, trusts, and real estate closings handled with care, based on 15 reviews at a 4.5 average. Recent reviews highlight attentive service and expertise in elder law and Medicaid planning, though the composite score is held back by lower recency and volume compared to firms higher on this list.
Pros
- Fast turnaround noted on time-sensitive matters
- Expertise in elder law and Medicaid planning
- Strong track record on real estate closings
- Recent reviews describe attentive, thorough service
Watch out: One older complaint described an unresolved will matter and lack of response, and some reviewers mention staff turnover.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Law Office of Summer R. Nichols
Why it ranks #14
The Law Office of Summer R. Nichols shows a genuinely mixed picture: satisfied clients praise the emotional support and communication from paralegals April Wooster and Darlene Lane during divorce cases, but a substantial share of reviewers describe being declined at consultation, going weeks without a response, or facing unexpected billing after a case was dismissed. The 3.9 average and lower sentiment score reflect that split.
Pros
- Paralegals named for consistent personal support
- Fast resolution reported when a case is fully retained
- Experience with uncontested and mediated divorces
- Clear explanation of legal steps when engaged
Watch out: Multiple reviewers describe being turned away or ignored at intake, limited direct attorney access, and several specifically cite being declined over legal insurance plans.
Services: loan modification
Luke Law LLC
Why it ranks #15
Luke Law LLC gets mostly positive marks at a 4.6 average across 33 reviews, with reviewers describing fast, friendly service across adoption, criminal defense, and vehicle title disputes rather than foreclosure work specifically. The composite score here is the lowest on this list, driven mainly by the recency of available review data rather than a drop in satisfaction.
Pros
- Reviewers report fast case resolution
- Flexible payment arrangements offered
- Named attorneys Gary Luke and Nathan Ross praised for responsiveness
- Covers a range of practice areas beyond foreclosure
Watch out: A minority of reviewers describe inconsistent quality depending on which attorney is assigned, including delayed court appearances.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation