Best foreclosure attorneys in Jacksonville
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Legal Department | 90 | 4.9 (112) | — | Business owners who want contracts and compliance handled right |
| 2 | Parker & DuFresne PA | 90 | 4.9 (441) | — | Bankruptcy filers who need their case moving fast |
| 3 | MAX STORY LAW | 86 | 4.9 (57) | — | Debt disputes, credit errors, and collection harassment |
| 4 | Ansbacher Law | 84 | 5 (28) | — | HOA and condo boards needing legal training |
| 5 | The Law Offices of Justin McMurray, P.A. | 70 | 4.3 (75) | — | Southside clients needing hands-on foreclosure or loan-mod help |
| 6 | Region Legal Service Office Southeast - Jacksonville | 62 | 3.8 (6) | — | Military members needing low-cost legal aid |
| 7 | Law Office of David C. Meltzer, PLLC | 56 | 5 (2) | — | A second opinion after a prior attorney fell short |
Ranked picks
The Legal Department
Why it ranks first
The Legal Department earns the top composite score in Jacksonville on the strength of near-perfect ratings and consistently positive feedback about clear, jargon-free explanations. Owners describe the team walking them through business formation, contracts, and audits with upfront fixed pricing and follow-up newsletters that keep companies in good standing.
Pros
- Transparent fixed-fee pricing instead of surprise billing
- Staff like Laurie Lee and Jena explain options in plain language
- Regular check-ins and newsletters to keep clients compliant
- Experience across mergers, acquisitions, and audits
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Parker & DuFresne PA
Why it ranks second
With 441 reviews and a 4.9 rating, Parker & DuFresne has by far the largest track record on this list, and the volume backs up the sentiment: clients repeatedly say Sandra Sartor and Greg Gilbert kept them informed and moved filings quickly (one reviewer got a skeleton petition in a month after a prior attorney sat on it for nine months). That speed matters when a foreclosure clock is running alongside a bankruptcy filing.
Pros
- Named staff (Sandra Sartor, Greg Gilbert, Don DuFresne) praised for patience
- Faster case progression than reviewers experienced elsewhere
- Upfront, published pricing
- Clients describe feeling supported through a hard process
Watch out: A reviewer with a disability flagged no working contact form or easy email option, making phone the main channel.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification
MAX STORY LAW
Why it ranks third
Max Story Law has a smaller review base than the top two firms but a very strong 4.9 rating and consistently positive sentiment. Clients say Max Story himself picks up calls and explains debt disputes and collection issues clearly, with junior partner Austin Griffin and staff member Lynette also named for follow-through.
Pros
- Accessible directly by phone for consultations
- Clear explanations of documents and options
- Track record of settlements and cash recovery
- Described as honest and empathetic by reviewers
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Ansbacher Law
Why it ranks fourth
Ansbacher Law's reviews come almost entirely from HOA board members and property professionals praising its certification courses, led by Triple Board-Certified Barry Ansbacher. Attendees say the material stays current with legal changes and that extended Q&A sessions turn abstract rules into practical answers, even for people who have served on boards for years.
Pros
- Board certification courses rated highly for clarity
- Extended live Q&A covering real-world scenarios
- Content kept current with pending legal changes
- Well-organized sessions with breaks and summaries
Watch out: Review volume (28) is lower than the top three, though every review is five stars.
Services: loan modification
The Law Offices of Justin McMurray, P.A.
Why it ranks fifth
This is the firm most directly tied to foreclosure work on this list, with reviewers pointing to real estate closings, loan modifications, and multi-year Chapter 13 cases handled by Ruben Rodriguez and Christina Lupoli. The rating sits lower than the firms above it because the sentiment is genuinely mixed: strong results when the firm is fully engaged, but a real pattern of slow follow-up and missed appointments when it isn't.
Pros
- Handles loan modifications and real estate closings, not just filings
- Clients report support through five-year Chapter 13 plans
- Open seven days with day-of consultations
- Staff described as knowledgeable when engaged
Watch out: Multiple reviewers describe slow communication, missed deadlines, and feeling rushed into settlements.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification, short sale deed in lieu
Region Legal Service Office Southeast - Jacksonville
Why it ranks sixth
Region Legal Service Office Southeast serves military clients and one reviewer specifically mentions a foreclosure matter, but the review base is thin (six reviews) and the sentiment is split between praise for staff warmth and a complaint about feeling dismissed. Treat this as a starting point for eligible service members rather than a first choice based on track record.
Pros
- Staff described as friendly and willing to help
- Broad service range including notary and estate planning
Watch out: One reviewer reported feeling dismissed on a foreclosure concern, and the review count is too small to draw firm conclusions.
Services: loan modification
Law Office of David C. Meltzer, PLLC
Why it ranks seventh
David C. Meltzer's firm has only two reviews, but the one detailed account describes a client who switched from another attorney and found this team responsive and confident handling foreclosure alternatives. The composite score reflects that thin sample, so it earns a place on the list rather than a strong recommendation.
Pros
- Reviewer switched from another firm and felt more confident here
- Described as responsive to client questions
Watch out: Only two reviews on record, so there is not enough data yet to judge consistency.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, short sale deed in lieu
The scoring behind this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 14% |
| Review recency | 12% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-27 · Full methodology ›