Best foreclosure attorneys in Fleming Island
This ranks the top 11 foreclosure attorneys serving Fleming Island by an earned composite score built from rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment, explained in full in our methodology.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eckert & Associates, PA | 88 | 4.8 (125) | — | Complex insurance & downtime claims |
| 2 | Cooper & Cooper, P.A. | 88 | 4.9 (72) | — | Family law & complex court matters |
| 3 | Head Moss Fulton & Griffin, PA | 81 | 4.7 (89) | — | Fast, smooth real estate closings |
| 4 | Law Offices of Jason K.S. Porter, P.A. | 75 | 5 (6) | — | Straight-talk, long-term counsel |
| 5 | Owenby Law, P.A. | 73 | 4.4 (94) | — | Experienced family law representation |
| 6 | Amber J. Hines, Esq., Attorney at Law | 71 | 4.6 (11) | — | Personalized family law guidance |
| 7 | Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne PLLC | 69 | 5 (3) | — | Patient guidance for first-time clients |
| 8 | Ansbacher Law | 66 | 5 (6) | — | HOA & condo board matters |
| 9 | Law Office of Rebecca Zima | 62 | 3.8 (10) | — | Divorce & custody with mediation option |
| 10 | Kenny Leigh & Associates | 57 | 3.2 (44) | — | High-stakes custody & asset disputes |
| 11 | William A Hamilton III Pa | 47 | 4 (4) | — | Real estate closings & title research |
Ranked picks
Eckert & Associates, PA
Why it ranks first
Eckert & Associates posts the highest composite score on this list, built on 125 reviews and a pattern of recovering money after insurers had already denied a claim. Named staff like Hannah, Lejuan, Billy Beech, Cassie Hanson, and Juan get called out repeatedly for staying in contact through drawn-out cases.
Pros
- Reopens and wins claims other firms and insurers stalled on
- Named case managers who give regular updates
- Deep repeat-client base with documented settlements
- Handles commercial vehicle and equipment loss cases end-to-end
Watch out: Several reviewers say the process runs long before a case settles, even when the outcome is worth it.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Cooper & Cooper, P.A.
Why it ranks second
Cooper & Cooper combines a near-perfect 4.9 rating across 72 reviews with sentiment that reads as consistently strong rather than just high-average. Attorneys Charlene, Tara, Michelle, and Kathy show up by name for explaining options clearly and picking up complicated cases on short notice.
Pros
- Responds fast even on short-notice, complex matters
- Explains legal options without pressure
- Strong track record in courtroom outcomes
- Upfront about fees and timelines
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Head Moss Fulton & Griffin, PA
Why it ranks third
Head Moss Fulton & Griffin backs up an 89-review sample with a reputation for closings that move without drama, driven by staff like Bridgett, Ali, Erin, and Katie who clients name again and again. Sentiment sits a bit lower than the top two firms because of a handful of recurring complaints.
Pros
- Organized, fast-moving closings
- Fair pricing and an accessible office
- Named staff clients return to repeatedly
- Clean, professional facilities
Watch out: Some reviewers flag slow responses on wiring details and a few dismissive front-desk interactions.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, short sale deed in lieu
Law Offices of Jason K.S. Porter, P.A.
Why it ranks fourth
Jason K.S. Porter draws a perfect rating and consistently positive sentiment from clients who describe years of follow-through and realistic, no-sugarcoating advice. The sample is only 6 reviews, so treat this as a strong early signal rather than a large-scale track record.
Pros
- Transparent about realistic outcomes and costs
- Consistent communication across multi-year engagements
Watch out: Review volume is still small, so weigh it alongside firms with a longer public track record.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Owenby Law, P.A.
Why it ranks fifth
Owenby Law brings 20+ years of Jacksonville-area family law experience and a 94-review sample, with named attorneys Katherine McLaurin, Emily Cochran, Sharnice Perry, and Renae Kenny earning frequent praise for knowledge and care during active cases. Sentiment is mixed mainly because of what happens after the case closes.
Pros
- Named attorneys with deep family law expertise
- Responsive and compassionate during active representation
- Clear explanation of strategy and process
- Prompt handling once a case is underway
Watch out: Multiple reviewers report slow retainer refunds and a billing department that's hard to reach after closure.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Amber J. Hines, Esq., Attorney at Law
Why it ranks sixth
Amber J. Hines gets consistent praise for listening closely to client goals and explaining options without rushing, with reviewers pointing to her handling of contested cases and genuine focus on children's welfare. The sample is just 11 reviews, so this is an emerging rather than long-established track record.
Pros
- Takes time to walk through options in detail
- Prioritizes client goals over speed
- Praised in contested case outcomes
- Personable and empathetic approach
Watch out: One reviewer voiced general skepticism about attorney motives, an outlier against otherwise positive feedback.
Services: loan modification
Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne PLLC
Why it ranks seventh
Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne earns a perfect rating from all three reviewers who mention approachable attorneys and patient handling of unfamiliar estate and family matters. John David Horne and staff member Carla are both named for kindness during difficult decisions.
Pros
- Approachable, patient attorneys
- Clear communication for first-time legal matters
Watch out: Only a handful of reviews so far, so it's worth confirming fit with a consultation.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Ansbacher Law
Why it ranks eighth
Ansbacher Law is board certified in real estate and construction law and gets specific praise for running HOA board certification training that holds attention over a four-hour session. Reviewers point to this HOA specialization as the clear reason to call them.
Pros
- Board certified in real estate and construction law
- Runs in-house HOA board certification training
Watch out: Recency on feedback is lower than most others here, so recent-year signal is thinner.
Services: loan modification
Law Office of Rebecca Zima
Why it ranks ninth
Rebecca Zima is a Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator with 30+ years claimed experience serving Clay, Duval, and St. Johns counties, and seven of ten reviewers describe her as a compassionate, knowledgeable advocate. The other three describe real problems worth knowing about going in.
Pros
- Certified family mediator, useful for less adversarial cases
- Long-claimed tenure in divorce and custody law
- Praised for thoroughness by most reviewers
- Serves a wide multi-county area
Watch out: About a third of reviewers cite missed calls, order-review errors, or effort not matching fees paid.
Services: loan modification
Kenny Leigh & Associates
Why it ranks tenth
Kenny Leigh & Associates shows a real split: named attorneys David and Melissa are credited with major wins in custody and asset recovery, while a large share of the 44-review sample describes escalating bills and stalled cases. The rating sits at 3.2, so go in with clear expectations.
Pros
- Named attorneys with documented custody and asset wins
- Responsive at the intake stage
- Handles complex, high-conflict litigation
- Individual attorney dedication praised by repeat clients
Watch out: Roughly half of reviewers report dropped communication, high escalating retainers, or slow progress, so lock in cost and update expectations upfront.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
William A Hamilton III Pa
Why it ranks #11
William A Hamilton III draws praise from three of four reviewers for sharp, reliable closing and title work, with the fourth review flagging a serious payoff error from years back. The sample is small and recency is at zero, so current standing is harder to confirm than for other firms here.
Pros
- Sharp legal work on closings
- Thorough title and property research
Watch out: One older review describes a mortgage payoff error the client says the office didn't own up to; confirm current standing before hiring.
Services: loan modification