Best foreclosure attorneys in Fleming Island
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eckert & Associates, PA | 89 | 4.8 (125) | — | Persistent recovery on stalled claims |
| 2 | Head Moss Fulton & Griffin, PA | 81 | 4.7 (90) | — | Real estate closings & title work |
| 3 | Law Offices of Jason K.S. Porter, P.A. | 75 | 5 (6) | — | Straight-talk counsel over multiple engagements |
| 4 | Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne PLLC | 69 | 5 (3) | — | Patient guidance through unfamiliar legal matters |
| 5 | Ansbacher Law | 66 | 5 (6) | — | HOA board certification & real estate law |
| 6 | William A Hamilton III Pa | 47 | 4 (4) | — | Title research on real estate transactions |
Ranked picks
Eckert & Associates, PA
Why it ranks first
Eckert & Associates posts the strongest composite score on this list, built on 125 reviews and a pattern of reopening cases that insurers or other firms had already written off. Named staff like Hannah, Lejuan, Billy Beech, Cassie Hanson, and Juan get repeated credit for staying in contact through long, multi-stage recoveries.
Pros
- Recovers settlements after insurers or prior counsel had stalled
- Named case staff who provide regular, clear updates
- Deep repeat-client base with documented multi-case wins
- High review volume backing a 4.8 rating
Watch out: Wait times on individual claims are described as long, even when the outcome is worthwhile, and one reviewer noted the firm no longer handles equipment damage claims outside of downtime recovery.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification
Head Moss Fulton & Griffin, PA
Why it ranks second
Head Moss Fulton & Griffin scores second overall on 90 reviews, with clients repeatedly singling out Ali Griffin, Bridgett Brown, and Erin Sullivan for smooth, unhurried closings and clear explanations of complex title and business legal matters. The Fleming Island office is described as accessible and easy to work with for both residential and business transactions.
Pros
- Named attorneys and staff known for responsiveness
- Handles both residential and business real estate closings
- Clean, wheelchair-accessible Fleming Island office
- Clear explanations of process without pressure
Watch out: A couple of reviews flag slow turnaround on wiring information and front-desk communication that felt insensitive to some clients.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, short sale deed in lieu, loan modification
Law Offices of Jason K.S. Porter, P.A.
Why it ranks third
Jason K.S. Porter's small but perfect review set (6 reviews, all 5 stars) points to a firm that clients return to across years, valued for setting realistic expectations rather than overpromising. That combination of consistency and transparency lands it in the middle of the pack despite the lower review volume.
Pros
- Transparent about realistic outcomes rather than sugarcoating
- Consistent communication across repeat engagements
Watch out: Only 6 reviews back this score, so treat the pattern as promising rather than fully proven.
Services: loan modification
Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne PLLC
Why it ranks fourth
Fuller, Dusinberre, Horne earns a perfect rating from a small pool of 3 reviewers who describe attorney John David Horne and staff member Carla as approachable and supportive through estate and family decisions that clients found difficult to navigate. It's a low-volume signal but a consistently positive one.
Pros
- Approachable attorneys for first-time legal clients
- Patient handling of unfamiliar or emotional situations
Watch out: Only 3 reviews are behind this score, so confidence here is low even though every review is positive.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification
Ansbacher Law
Why it ranks fifth
Ansbacher Law stands out for HOA and condo law specifically, with reviewers praising instructors who kept a four-hour board certification course engaging and answered real questions from board members. It's a narrower niche than general foreclosure defense, but the expertise is well documented in what reviews exist.
Pros
- Board certified in real estate and construction law
- In-house HOA board member certification training
Watch out: Based on only 6 reviews with a lower recency score than others on this list, so recent activity is thinner.
Services: loan modification
William A Hamilton III Pa
Why it ranks sixth
William A Hamilton III's firm gets credit from reviewers for sharp closing work and thorough title and property research, but the composite score is pulled down by low review recency and one older, serious complaint about a mortgage payoff error that the office blamed on the client. Worth a call for straightforward title work, with eyes open on that history.
Pros
- Knowledgeable staff on closings and title research
- Handles complex real estate transactions
Watch out: One reviewer describes a critical payoff error where the office reportedly blamed the client instead of acknowledging its own mistake.
Services: loan modification
The scoring behind this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 14% |
| Review recency | 12% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-27 · Full methodology ›