Jacksonville Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu

Foreclosure Defense Litigation in Orange Park

Foreclosure Defense Litigation in Jacksonville Metro

Foreclosure defense litigation is what happens when a homeowner facing a foreclosure lawsuit fights back in court rather than letting the case go by default. In Florida, foreclosures are judicial, meaning the lender has to sue and prove its case before a judge, which gives a homeowner real chances to slow the process, challenge the lender's paperwork, or negotiate a better outcome than losing the house outright. An attorney in this space typically reviews the mortgage note and assignment history for defects, files an answer and affirmative defenses to the complaint, contests standing (whether the plaintiff actually has the right to foreclose), and works the case through mediation, motion practice, or trial if needed. Many also negotiate loan modifications, short sales, or deed-in-lieu arrangements alongside the litigation track.

Orange Park has 16 attorneys and firms listed in this category, ranging from solo practitioners to larger consumer-defense firms. When comparing them, look at how much of their practice is actually dedicated to foreclosure defense versus general real estate or bankruptcy work, how they handle communication once a case is filed, whether they've taken cases to trial or only handle settlements, and what their fee structure looks like relative to the stage your case is at.

Our scoring weighs verified client feedback, responsiveness, experience specific to foreclosure litigation, and consistency of outcomes, so you can compare firms on more than just star ratings. See the full breakdown in our ranked guide to Orange Park foreclosure attorneys, and read our scoring methodology for how we build these rankings.

Get matched with foreclosure defense litigation in Orange Park

Free, no obligation. Tell us about your situation and we'll match you with qualified foreclosure attorneys.

Get matched

All foreclosure defense litigation in Orange Park, ranked by score and relevance

16 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is foreclosure defense litigation, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Sermons Law, PLLC
#1
87

Sermons Law, PLLC

4.9(187)✓ Google-verified

Nearly every reviewer experienced attentive staff who explain legal steps clearly and return calls within 24 hours. Clients feel heard during stressful times, with named attorneys like Markus Sermons, Kyle Marcil, and Jahlysa Jenkins praised for professionalism and follow-through on wills, probate, custody, and estate disputes. Two reviewers flagged billing concerns: one was charged unexpectedly for a consultation, another disputed an additional charge after a five-month guardianship case. The firm's website lists services far beyond foreclosure (divorce, probate, adoption), though most reviews reflect estate and family law work rather than the loan modification or foreclosure defense the directory highlights.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Donley Law Firm, PLLC
#2
87

Donley Law Firm, PLLC

4.8(96)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently praise Mr. Donley and his team for being accessible, honest, and genuinely invested in outcomes. They value clear explanations of legal steps and prompt answers to questions, which made stressful situations feel manageable. Staff including paralegals and Mrs. Amber Donley are noted as knowledgeable and supportive. Cases span criminal defense, juvenile representation, and traffic matters, with clients highlighting swift resolutions and favorable results. Fees are mentioned as reasonable and affordable.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
The Law Offices Of Ron Sholes, P.A.
#3
87

The Law Offices Of Ron Sholes, P.A.

4.7(122)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently report fast, personal service from staff who keep them fully informed at every step. Blair Butler, Robyn, Mia, and other named team members stand out for treating clients like family, answering questions promptly, and securing settlements quickly-sometimes resolving property damage within 48 hours or full settlements within three months. The firm handles auto accident cases with professional expertise and genuine care during stressful times. Multiple reviewers mention feeling supported rather than like "just another case," and several note they'd return to the firm or recommend it to others without hesitation.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Morgan & Morgan
#4
82

Morgan & Morgan

4.8(1708)✓ Google-verified

Morgan & Morgan handles personal injury and accident cases across Jacksonville, and new clients often report smooth initial engagement. However, several reviewers describe weeks-long response delays once work begins, alleged withholding of settlement information, and resistance to transferring case files, raising concerns about follow-through on larger claims.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Empowerment Legal, PLLC
#5
81

Empowerment Legal, PLLC

4.9(17)✓ Google-verified

Ms. Parr earned respect from veterans, immigrants, and opposing counsel alike. Her practice handles VA disability claims (often without upfront fees), family law, and immigration defense. Reviewers describe a lawyer who listens, communicates clearly, tracks down missing parties, and fights hard-whether getting a dismissed injunction at the first hearing or securing asylum approval after bouncing between detention facilities. What sets her apart: free initial claims for veterans, honest case screening (she refers clients elsewhere if she cannot help), prior military service that veterans trust, and a small team that stays with cases from start to finish. Reviewers across three states repeatedly mention feeling heard and cared for, which is rare in immigration and benefits work.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation

Get matched with foreclosure defense litigation in Orange Park

Free, no obligation. Tell us about your situation and we'll match you with qualified foreclosure attorneys.

Get matched
Berg Bryant Elder Law Group, PLLC
#6
78

Berg Bryant Elder Law Group, PLLC

4.7(15)✓ Google-verified

Staff here earn high marks for listening carefully, explaining legal steps in plain language, and guiding families through elder care decisions step by step. Reviewers specifically name Carla, Shelby, Cristian, Jenn, and Kellen as responsive and patient, especially when handling Medicaid qualification and power of attorney work.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Owenby Law, P.A.
#7
76

Owenby Law, P.A.

4.5(279)✓ Google-verified

Owenby Law excels with individual attorneys who earn strong praise for knowledge, responsiveness, and genuine client care, especially in family law. Many clients report feeling heard, supported, and satisfied with outcomes. However, systemic problems undermine trust: communication breakdowns mean clients miss mediation notices or learn of case changes via email, receptionist staff have been described as rude, and accounting delays retainer refunds for months. Several reviewers note the firm appears over-capacity, with one claiming attorneys carry 50+ cases each. High five-star volume masks recurring complaints about access and follow-through. Service varies sharply by attorney assigned. Kyra Lucas-Millbrook, Briana Leshinsky, Renae Kenny, Dustin Nemati, and Sharnice Perry draw consistent praise for advocacy and care. Yet some clients report dropping the firm mid-engagement due to poor handoff practices, incomplete filings, and unresponsive billing. The mismatch between individual attorney quality and firm-level operational issues creates real risk for clients.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
David A. King
#8
75 low data

David A. King

4.9(16)

Clients consistently describe David King as deeply knowledgeable, responsive, and organized, with long-standing relationships spanning decades. Most reviews focus on his estate planning and real estate expertise rather than foreclosure or loan modification matters.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Henry & Henry Law Firm
#9
73 low data

Henry & Henry Law Firm

4.9(27)✓ Google-verified

Todd Henry and his staff earned strong trust across 26 of 27 reviews by staying present through clients' cases, explaining steps clearly, and treating people with genuine respect during vulnerable moments. One client reported feeling overcharged on a bankruptcy filing that never proceeded to completion, citing excessive fees for phone calls and unfulfilled refund promises.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Taylor, Glenn A PA
#10
72 low data

Taylor, Glenn A PA

4.6(25)✓ Google-verified

Most clients praise Glenn Taylor for swift, professional real estate closings and staff responsiveness. The office handles title work across the Jacksonville metro area, though reviewers note the single Orange Park location is a drawback for some.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationShort Sale & Deed-in-Lieu NegotiationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Tolson & Associates, PA
#11
68 low data

Tolson & Associates, PA

4.5(15)✓ Google-verified

Most clients praise Tolson & Associates for estate planning, trusts, and real estate closings done with care and promptness. One older complaint flagged an unresolved will matter and lack of response, though the bulk of recent reviews highlight attentive service and strong expertise in elder law and Medicaid planning.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Law Office of Tony Turner Orange Park Bankruptcy Lawyer
#12
81

Law Office of Tony Turner Orange Park Bankruptcy Lawyer

4.6(78)✓ Google-verified

Tony Turner's office earned a 4.6 rating across 78 reviews, with 88% five-star feedback. Clients consistently praise the team's responsiveness, patience during stressful bankruptcy filings, and willingness to explain every step. Tony and his staff member Nancy are named repeatedly as compassionate professionals who guide clients through Chapter 7 cases and help stop wage garnishment. A handful of complaints cite disorganized intake delays and one instance of hostile phone conduct, though these are vastly outnumbered by accounts of successful outcomes and genuine care.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Luke Law LLC
#13
63 low data

Luke Law LLC

4.6(33)✓ Google-verified

Most clients report fast, friendly service and favorable outcomes. A minority had poor experiences with specific attorneys, citing delayed court appearances and weak representation. The firm spans multiple practice areas; reviews speak most often to adoption, criminal defense, and vehicle title disputes rather than foreclosure or loan modification.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Kopelousos, Bradley & Garrison, P.A.
#14
56 low data

Kopelousos, Bradley & Garrison, P.A.

4.7(3)

Limited review evidence suggests positive experiences. The one review on file calls them great lawyers, though detail is sparse.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Burney Bivens & Associates PA
#15
52 low data

Burney Bivens & Associates PA

4.4(10)

Most reviewers found the attorney accessible and willing to answer questions directly. One reviewer expressed strong dissatisfaction with the attorney's demeanor and professionalism.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Mary Cobb Attorney at Law
#16
49 low data

Mary Cobb Attorney at Law

4.0(8)

Mary Cobb delivers solid legal work on probate and estate matters at reasonable rates, but some clients find her manner during consultations stiff and impersonal. Fans praise her expertise and value; critics note she can come across as distant and dismissive of client concerns.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense Litigation

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes would you like?

Sending this enquiry means you agree we can pass it to providers relevant to your request.

Enquiries from this site's contact forms may be shared with partner providers who can complete the work, and we may earn a fee. Our rankings and scores come from our published method only and are not affected by referral fees.

Common questions about foreclosure defense litigation

How much does foreclosure defense litigation cost in Orange Park?
Most attorneys in this category charge either a flat fee for filing an answer and handling early motions (often a few thousand dollars) or an hourly rate if the case goes further into discovery, mediation, or trial. Some firms offer payment plans since foreclosure clients are often dealing with financial strain. Get a written fee agreement upfront and ask what's included if the case drags on for months, which is common in judicial foreclosure.
How often do homeowners actually need this kind of attorney?
You need one as soon as you're served with a foreclosure complaint, not after. Florida requires a response within 20 days, and missing that window can lead to a default judgment even if you had valid defenses. Homeowners behind on payments but not yet sued may still benefit from a consultation to understand their options before a lawsuit is filed.
What should I expect once I hire a foreclosure defense attorney?
Expect an initial review of your loan documents and payment history, then a filed answer with defenses within the response deadline. From there the case typically moves into mediation (Florida courts often require or encourage it) and possibly motions or a trial date. Timelines vary widely, from a few months to well over a year, depending on court backlog and whether the lender is willing to negotiate.
How can I judge whether a foreclosure attorney is any good?
Ask directly how many foreclosure cases they've handled in the past year, whether they've argued contested motions or gone to trial (versus only negotiating), and how they communicate case updates. A firm that treats foreclosure defense as a side practice tends to be less current on standing and documentation defenses than one that focuses on it regularly.

Last updated 2026-08-27